Gollum, Silent Slinker // Meager Meal

Not legal in this format after release.

Not legal in this format after release.

A four-mana 4/3 menace with a minor Adventure is far below Modern's rate; unlike Seasoned Pyromancer, it offers no cards or immediate board impact.

Could be wrong if An unprovided +1/+1-counter or Adventure shell could value the cheap first spell more than expected.

Legacy demands exceptional efficiency; this slow, removable combat creature lacks the unique utility of comparable Barrowgoyf or Emry.

Could be wrong if Unrevealed interactions that exploit casting an Adventure or placing counters could create a fringe niche.

The Adventure makes this a two-spell package, but a four-mana 4/3 menace is weak beside Pauper's efficient threats and value creatures.

Could be wrong if A competitive black counter-focused shell could make the one-mana Adventure a meaningful enabler.

A single +1/+1 counter and four-mana 4/3 menace have little multiplayer impact and are highly replaceable even in counter decks.

Could be wrong if A future commander specifically rewarding Adventures or counters could make the package more desirable.

A 4/3 menace is a solid four-drop, and casting Meager Meal first converts one card into two relevant spells despite the life concession.

Could be wrong if Unknown speed, removal, and counter synergies could move a four-mana low-toughness threat substantially up or down.