Kirk, Enterprising Captain
CommentsModern 21 Eng.FUsr.—
Four mana for a removal-vulnerable creature with delayed, board-dependent card access is far below Modern's required impact rate; even Ugin, Eye of the Storms is only 45.
Could be wrong if An unusually efficient creature-combo shell that naturally reaches 8 power could create a narrow home.
Legacy 17 Eng.FUsr.—
Legacy's cheap interaction and fast engines make a four-mana combat-only value creature implausible. It is closer to Petrified Hamlet's 20 than Consider's 47.
Could be wrong if Ancient Tomb deployment and a new creature shell could permit isolated testing, though the trigger remains slow.
Commander 43 Eng.D+Usr.—
Go-wide combat decks can meet 8 power easily and turn attacks into cards, but Kirk must survive a turn and attack; this is a niche role-player below Commander's Sphere's 55.
Could be wrong if High token density or reliable haste in a commander shell could make its repeated impulse draw more attractive.
Limited 72 Eng.B+Usr.—
A 4/3 menace is difficult to trade with, and established boards can turn each attack into another card. It is premium but not a standalone bomb like Aang and Katara.
Could be wrong if Unknown format speed, removal, and token support determine how often 8 power is online safely.
“A fragile four-mana attacker whose conditional attack trigger rewards established board presence, with Limited its clearest home.”
AI prediction made before release — not a measured result. Real performance data replaces this once the set is legal and tournament results come in.
Your rating, on the same 0–100 scale the engine uses.
5 ratings are needed on a format before its community average is shown publicly beside the engine's.
Comments 0